When UK dealers taking part in the scrappage incentive scheme invoice for new cars exchanged for scrapped clunkers, they will find that the £2,000 allowance is VAT-inclusive. Manufacturers passing on the £1,000 allowance they receive from the Government can reduce their input tax on the sale of the new car by £130, leaving a net contribution of £870 from the taxpayer, based on the current temporarily discounted 15% tax rate.

Discussing the scheme, Auto Retail Bulletin's May issue helpfully notes that when it went live on 18 May, it was still not clear how HMRC would treat the VAT involved in the scheme, particularly where it may involve VAT-registered light commercial vehicle dealers who would not normally pay VAT at the point of sale.

The scheme has been introduced with an apparent lack of joined-up government among the government departments and agencies involved, and with apparently an at best lukewarm blessing from The Treasury. As Professor Garel Rhys has noted, it stands to boost the sales of a number of dealers, but only those of Nissan among the UK's remaining car plants, since 86% of UK-sold new cars are imported, and the rest are all far beyond the reach of those who've made do with old bangers.

Some of us think all scrappage schemes are market-distorting and create sated consumers to dampen a future recovery based on consumer confidence in paying real, sustainable market prices. At least in the UK scheme's case, it hasn't been clouded with dubious claims of environmental benefits. And we can take comfort from the modesty of the UK scheme. The Germans have spent €2.5bn on allowing clunker owners to swap ancient Polos for cheaper new Porsches should they wish, and they can buy them in Poland if they prefer.

While we estimate that if the average price of a scrappage incentive-driven new car purchase in the UK is £8,500 or so, the Government's £3,000,000 budget for the scheme will be more or less recouped by VAT receipts that HMRC would not have had without the scheme. So at least the rest of us won't have to pay for other people's new cars.

Toby Procter
18 May